The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) is buzzing with anticipation for Captain America: Brave New World, the first solo movie with Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) officially taking on the mantle of Captain America. As the sequel to The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, fans are eager to see how Sam navigates his new role in a world grappling with complex political and societal challenges. While Marvel has been characteristically secretive, fans have pieced together trailers, casting news, and comic book lore to form some exciting theories. Let’s dive into the top fan theories surrounding Brave New World.
1. The Rise of the Serpent Society
One of the most popular theories is that the Serpent Society, a group of villains with deep comic book roots, will play a pivotal role. This theory gained traction after the movie’s earlier working title was revealed to be Captain America: New World Order—a phrase tied to the group’s agenda of global domination. Fans speculate that Samuel Sterns/The Leader (played by Tim Blake Nelson) could recruit the Serpent Society, using their influence to sow chaos and pit the world against Captain America.
The Serpent Society could also serve as a metaphor for Sam’s challenge of uniting a fractured world. If this theory holds, expect thematic undertones exploring trust, leadership, and the global perception of a Black Captain America.
2. Hulk Legacy Ties and the Gamma Connection
The return of Samuel Sterns, aka The Leader, from 2008’s The Incredible Hulk, hints at a significant gamma-related storyline. Fans theorize that Sterns may be conducting experiments to create gamma-enhanced super-soldiers or even mutate regular people, leading to a new kind of biological warfare.
Some believe this could tie into the rumored reappearance of Betty Ross (Liv Tyler) and her father, Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross (now played by Harrison Ford). Ross, who is now the U.S. president, might have secret plans to militarize gamma technology, further complicating Sam’s efforts to uphold ethical leadership.
3. A Tense Showdown with Thunderbolt Ross
With Harrison Ford stepping into the role of Thunderbolt Ross, fans speculate that his character will clash with Sam Wilson over what it means to protect America. Ross’s history of authoritarian tendencies could manifest in the form of draconian policies or a government-sanctioned super-soldier initiative.
A widely discussed theory is that Ross might transform into Red Hulk, either as a climactic twist or a post-credits reveal. This would set up a potential confrontation not just between Sam and Ross but between Sam’s idealistic vision of America and Ross’s militaristic, power-driven approach.
4. The Return of Steve Rogers?
Fans can’t stop wondering about Chris Evans’ potential return as Steve Rogers. While Marvel has been tight-lipped, the movie’s focus on legacy opens the door for Steve to make a cameo.
One intriguing theory suggests that Sam might seek Steve’s advice (or even a flashback) during a moment of self-doubt. Another, more outlandish theory is that an older Steve Rogers might come out of retirement for one final mission, symbolizing a “passing of the torch” moment that solidifies Sam’s role as Captain America in the eyes of the world.
5. The Wakandan Connection
After The Falcon and the Winter Soldier ended with Bucky in Wakanda and Sam wielding a vibranium shield, fans believe Brave New World might explore more ties to Wakanda. Could Shuri or Okoye play a role in helping Sam navigate a new global crisis?
Some even speculate that Wakanda might be a target of the Serpent Society or Thunderbolt Ross, given their technological superiority and isolationist policies. This would force Sam to balance his allegiance to global peace with his respect for Wakanda’s sovereignty.
6. Isaiah Bradley’s Legacy
The Falcon and the Winter Soldier introduced Isaiah Bradley, a forgotten Black super-soldier whose story added layers to the MCU’s exploration of systemic injustice. Fans hope Brave New World will continue his arc, possibly with a larger role for his grandson Eli Bradley, who becomes Patriot in the comics.
A prominent theory is that Isaiah might inspire Sam to redefine what Captain America stands for—one who represents justice not just for America, but for marginalized voices globally. This theme would reinforce Sam’s unique perspective on the shield and the symbol it represents.
7. A Multiversal Surprise
With the MCU increasingly delving into the multiverse, some fans believe Brave New World could feature surprise appearances from alternate versions of Captain America. One theory suggests that a Hydra-controlled Steve Rogers from another dimension might make an appearance, testing Sam’s moral resolve.
Another idea is that multiversal chaos could bring characters like Peggy Carter’s Captain Carter or even an alternate Sam Wilson into the story. While this might seem far-fetched, Marvel loves its surprises, and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness has proven anything is possible.
8. A Tease for the Young Avengers
The MCU has been quietly assembling the pieces for the Young Avengers, and Brave New World could play a crucial role. With Isaiah Bradley’s grandson Eli already introduced, fans theorize the movie might hint at the Young Avengers’ formation.
This could take the form of a mentorship dynamic between Sam and Eli, where Sam guides the young hero in grappling with legacy, responsibility, and heroism. Such a subplot would further anchor the movie in themes of generational change.
Conclusion
Captain America: Brave New World has all the ingredients to be a pivotal chapter in the MCU. From political intrigue and global threats to personal growth and legacy, the movie promises to tackle complex issues while delivering the action-packed spectacle fans love. Whether it’s the rise of the Serpent Society, the return of Steve Rogers, or the introduction of new heroes, one thing is certain: fans can’t wait to see how Sam Wilson soars as the new Captain America.
What’s your favorite theory about Brave New World? Let us know in the comments!